This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

No time to read? Listen on SPOTIFY!

Vol 1 | Issue 30 | ISSN 2979-8744 (online)

I've been thinking a great deal about the growing number of screenwriters who have invested in training, built strong portfolios and achieved recognition through competitions and development schemes, yet still struggle to secure their first professional writing credit. 

Are they missing something? Is their writing not ready? Or has the industry become less equipped to develop the talent it identifies? 

I spoke to John Yorke about what makes writers stand out, the difference between talent and professional readiness, and what we can expect when the opportunities to learn while earning begin to disappear.  

John has spent more than two decades developing writers and stories for British television. A former BBC drama executive and the creator of the BBC Writers' Academy, he's worked with writers at every stage of their careers, from emerging talent to some of the industry's most recognisable names. And now provides courses (which I can personally say are excellent) at JohnYorkeStory.com 

He's also refreshingly candid about the limitations of writer development. I’ve tried not to edit this down too much as John’s insights are so brilliant, so go grab a cuppa before you get stuck in! 

You've read and developed an enormous number of scripts over your career. What separates a good script from one that makes you want to work with the writer? Is it always about the quality of the script itself? 

John Yorke: No, it's not. The fundamental rule I've always followed is really simple. It’s just to ask “do I keep reading to the end without stopping?”

Of all the writers I helped discover, particularly in my early days, people like Neil Cross, you'd read their work and at the end of the script you'd pick up the phone, ring the agent and say, "Can I meet them?" Simply because, if the script was impossible to put down, then there’s a very good chance that’s what a viewer would engage in the same way too.

The art of screenwriting I’ve always felt, is above all to create that one important question in the reader's mind: “what happens next?” And not just that, but “if I don't find out what happens next now, my life will be miserable?” That's what you're after fundamentally, because that's what makes a hit series.

There are caveats. While narrative drive is always the most important consideration, I worked with a lot of very junior writers, people who weren't particularly good at the beginning, and while they hadn’t always mastered the basics, they often had something that just made them different.

You were looking for an idea or a turn of phrase, something that made you laugh, something that said, "My God, this person has talent." And then - if you can just give them the space and time to develop that talent - which I could at the time – there’s a good chance they could turn into something really special.

But of course that's an indulgence only the most generous companies can afford. It requires investment.

And I guess with the industry being so risk-averse at the moment, that investment is quite limited. I've spoken to producers who simply don't have the development funds. What does that mean for emerging writers? 

John: That's the fundamental problem. There's almost no paid space in which the industry  can develop new talent.

It's incredibly unfair because it privileges the more privileged. That's not to dismiss anyone who comes from a privileged background, because they can be great writers too. But it does mean you limit the voices of the minorities that always get kicked out of television. They’re always the first to suffer.

Helen: Which is interesting when there are so many initiatives trying to bring more working-class and diverse voices into the industry.

John: I don't think most of them really work that well, because the only type of investment that produces guaranteed returns is long term investment. It’s very hard to learn anything in three weeks. You learn by sitting, listening, writing, failing, writing, failing, writing, failing, writing, getting it right.

Of course, it's made even harder because the Amazon rainforest of drama, the Continuing Drama landscape, has been decimated, so the training field has shrunk almost beyond comprehension. It seems crazy now, but the reason I started the Writers' Academy in 2005, was because we couldn't find enough good writers to write our shows. We were making around 500 hours a year. Now it's so different.

Thinking about the Writers' Academy and other development initiatives, what do writers commonly misunderstand about the selection process? What would make an application memorable for the right reasons? 

John: When we selected for the Writers' Academy, we had about 500 or 600 applications every year. We got people from Continuing Drama, the independent production companies and BBC Studios involved, and we did a big mass read of the first ten pages of everything.

The simple question we asked the readers was, "Would you like to read more?"

Everything was read at least twice, but the key thing was always coming back to “would you like to read more?” There are certain things in those first ten pages that allow to tell really quickly if a writer has got something. The first is the writer's ability to handle exposition – that’s the main tell, but also the ability to dramatise turning points plausibly. If you see those two things you’ve normally got something.

Then if you add to that “Are you intrigued? Is it asking questions you'd like the answers to, but not giving them to you?” you can pretty much see a writer who has got something. If we could detect a basic ability to withhold and manipulate the flow of information we started to get quite excited. But without that, there was one other thing too – “is there anything here that’s unique?”

I remember Mark Catley, who became an incredibly important writer on Casualty. His first script was a mess, but it captured a working-class northern voice that I hadn't heard convincingly since Paul Abbott.

When I ran EastEnders, we'd sometimes read scripts and think, “I don't think that feels really real. I don't think that's reflective of working-class life”. We were desperate to find that next Jimmy McGovern, that next Frank Cottrell-Boyce, Tony Jordan, people who knew how to write that world. And you could see with Mark that he had that. He just didn't understand how to structure it.

And that gets us to the other main point about training - You can't really teach voice, but you can teach structure. That's why I've spent so long teaching people structure, because it's the one thing you can teach that doesn't damage them.

Do you think voice is something writers can develop, or is it something you either have or you don't? 

John: I think the more you write, the more your voice develops, and the more mature you become, the more sophisticated you get at putting that voice down and understanding what you want to say about the world. But I don't think you can teach it.

What you can do, and again this requires investment, is provide a safe space to fail.

When I came from Channel 4 to the BBC in 2004, the shows were desperate for new writers, but new writers weren't coming through. I looked at the failure rate for new writers and it was something like 90%. It was extraordinarily high because they were only given one script, and when that didn’t work, which it usually didn’t, they were kicked off and rewritten by whoever was the lead writer that day. And I remember thinking “what an awful system. It just doesn’t work “

So the task of training then, became to provide a safety net so a writer could develop over two or three scripts without fear of being sacked. We provided a hammock which allowed them to fall off their tightrope a few times. If you do that you see amazing progress – in a year you see all the signs they can do it, and they can articulate their own voice properly.

There's a growing population of writers who've undertaken training, developed strong portfolios and had success in schemes and competitions, but haven't yet secured that first professional writing credit. What would you encourage them to focus on next? 

John: Well, there are the obvious things, like do you have an agent? But it’s important to remember that there is one giant piece of subtext underlying every recruiting decision – and it comes in the form of a question: “can this person make me money?”

So a new writer has got to get a script to the right person, the one who makes recruitment decision or can pass them up the chain to those that do. To get that to happen, and I'm trying very hard not to be conservative about this, it makes more sense if you write something that you might see on television - something that is commercially viable.

A writer needs to understand what BBC One makes, what Channel 4 makes, what Netflix makes. To understand that ITV makes a lot of police-related shows and detective shows, because that's where a commercial audience goes. It's thinking along those lines.

There's a tendency, and I'm exaggerating massively, for young writers to not do that, but instead submit scripts which say, “here's why I'm right about the world and you are wrong”, Nobody wants that – what they want is something sellable, or something that explores the writers world and the contradictions within it. And ideally both.

Who is your audience? Why does Happy Valley work? Because the vast majority of terrestrial audiences are females over 55, and so if you have a female protagonist who represents them shows them they're not useless, that they’re brilliant and valuable and visible, then you can see why people might watch it. Thinking like that, understanding that, really helps.

At the same time you don't want writers to lose what's innate about themselves. What is your voice? What is the thing you're obsessed about? How can you marry that with what television wants to make? How can you smuggle that into the very limited types of shows that TV normally wants?

The other way of course is to get work on an existing show. Take Neil Cross again. He was a novelist who wrote action adventure with a political slant. A good agent will thus ask something like: “who makes shows like that?” And in his case Kudos did – they made Spooks.  So then you’re selling to someone who wants to buy the thing you specialise in, that makes you unique. That’s what happened with Neil. A script editor read his novel and said, "Why don't we give him episode four?" I read episode four, and out of that, eventually, came Luther.

That brings me to calling-card scripts. There's always a debate about whether you should write something that demonstrates your own voice, even if it's quite ambitious, or something that reflects the kind of television being made. What would you advise? 

John: There's this massive gap between Britain and America, because in America you write a spec for the show you want to work on. “Can you get the voice of our show?” In Britain, historically, it's been, oh, we don't do that. The question the British seem to ask is “Can you be unique and an artist?” I think that's slightly silly, frankly.

I think young writers should write a spec every year at least, because their competitors will be. That means you’ll have something that’s contemporary, but you’ll also of course be improving your talent. So much of writing is about flying hours - about endless practice.

Every time I've championed a writer, it's because I've gone, either "Oh my God, this is great." Or “this COULD be great”. I’ve never really think beyond that. When you read a great story, the real world slips away, time stops and you're feeling what the protagonist feels. So if you get that feeling then there’s gold in your hands.  A good script will drug it’s readers – will inject them with dopamine and adrenalin so they’ll end up thinking: "Oh my God, I've got to keep reading." Then if they they’ll say to their colleagues "My God, you've got to read this.", you kick start the chain that sends their work viral. That’s why emotion in a script  is so important – if you can make your reader laugh or cry then you are over half way to getting them to calling you in to meet.

In the last years of the Writers' Academy, we developed a new admissions test. We said, “write one page of A4 that makes us laugh or cry. Anything you like. Just tell us a story”. It's really hard. But my God, the people who could do it turned out to be brilliant.

I've been involved in a couple of development schemes, and I think there's sometimes a misconception that getting selected is going to change everything. That you'll suddenly get an agent or work. But it's what you put in before, during and especially afterwards that really makes these work. 

John: They can be really good, these schemes. But – and this is going to sound annoying - the reason why the Writers' Academy worked, and why 80% of its graduates are still working in the industry over 20 years later, is not because I'm a genius, as my son keeps reminding me. It’s because of the flying hours.

It's simply because if you train writers for three months in the skills you can teach, story structure - and then you give them three chances to write a proper TV show without being sacked,  they just have a much higher chance of learning their craft, surviving those first few years, and then prospering.

It's kind of as simple and complicated as that. It's why nothing else can work as well as that. 

There are writers who keep investing in courses, schemes and retreats without necessarily giving themselves time to test what they've learned and go away and write. Learning can become quite addictive, but also a distraction from doing the work. 

John: There's no substitute for getting in front of an audience and seeing what works and what doesn't. That's why soap is such a brilliant education, because you very quickly see what an audience responds too.

When we talk about emerging talent, writers might think it means they've written some scripts, done some learning and are moving forward. But from a producer's or script editor's perspective, what makes a writer professionally ready? 

John: If you're a professional production company, you're looking for something that you can make, that you can sell. And often with new writers, you're not getting something you can sell. So the question is, why not?

Is it the content? Is it the treatment of the content? Is it the idea, the structure, the voice? They're all variables. What's stopping somebody from enjoying that script as a completely immersive experience? And often it's just that the new writer is not skilled enough.

I think it's really instructive if you look at James Graham. You read a couple of his really early plays and they're not actually very good. But what you see in each successive one is this extraordinary intellectual development, this sense of, "Oh, that's how it works."

And then he finds this brilliant idea for This House. He found his subject, absolutely right for that National Theatre audience at that time. And he also suddenly nailed structure, character, shape, all in one.

His story I find inspiring. You start writing, you're not very good, but you know you've got something to say. You're passionate about it, and you finally find a way to unlock how to tell your subject. And then if you’re lucky, what you have to say is the perfect subject for your target audience.

In terms of approaching independent production companies, who should emerging writers be contacting? Development producers, script editors, assistants? Or should they simply be cheeky and ask everyone? 

John: You can do that. A lot of companies won't even read your stuff, because it costs them money and opens them up to charges of plagiarism. If you’re lucky you’ll find a company who might read it, but it’s sadly not a priority for most companies – what they want are writers who get green lights, and so they tend to chase the Stephen Knights or Jack Thornes of this world.

A lot of the most successful writers I've known just got work in production companies. They became runners or worked on productions, because it gave them the chance to a personal connection, and of course that makes such a difference.

I think I’ve had four PAs over the years who said, "I've written a script." Three of them went on to have careers.

There's nothing better than that, or forming a personal relationship with a researcher or indeed anyone in a company. Because as they go up, they'll take you with them if they like you. Of course you can send stuff to people, but nothing beats a personal relationship.

Before we finish, is there anything else you'd like to add? 

John: I don't do as much of this as I used to, but I was obsessed with it for years. I've been frustrated by endless schemes, and that's because I look at them and think, well, that's not going to work.

I'm really not saying don't do schemes. They can be really good, some are excellent – but you just have to remember they’re aren’t a golden ticket to a career.

I think BBC Writers are very good. Jess does an amazing job, and I would always recommend them. But even they're limited by how many people they can get into an ecosystem when that ecosystem has, over the last 15 years, dramatically shrunk in size.

The world that allowed us to do what we did successfully for 20 years just doesn't exist any more. That doesn’t mean it’s impossible to create good training schemes, but to do so requires a collective will at the very top. But inevitably, they’re always the people, and it's not to indict any of them, that don’t have time to engage, and often aren’t able to see a benefit that will only arrive, three, four or five years down the line.

The one thing that really does scare me though is that, while each year we are chopping down more and more of the rainforest that has sustained our writing community, we are increasingly only going to left with a very small pool of people who can afford the time and investment it takes to develop real talent. And just can’t be good for the industry.

Final thoughts 

I'm enormously grateful to John for his time and for sharing so much of his experience. 

What I particularly appreciated was hearing from someone who has witnessed such significant changes in the industry, because I think it's easy for those of us who are relatively new to screenwriting to overlook just how different things once were. 

My own experience has largely been shaped by the industry post-COVID and the writers' strikes. It's difficult to fully understand what's been lost when you weren't around to experience it in the first place, and all too easy to pine after a time gone by much like we do with nostalgia.

And while there are some excellent development schemes operating today, John's description of the Writers' Academy made me think about the opportunities writers once had to learn while actually doing the job. To write, get things wrong, receive feedback and have another go, without necessarily losing their chance of a career. 

Of course, a system like that costs money. It requires broadcasters and production companies to invest in writers who might not deliver anything commercially successful for several years. 

And that's what I keep coming back to. 

If the industry can continue commissioning programmes using the talent it already knows, where's the incentive to invest in the writers who might be ready in another three or five years? 

Helen 

Next up... I co-created a showcase, did the industry show up? 

© Helen Tompson 2026 | Feel free to share this newsletter with other writers. If you'd like to reproduce or quote larger sections, just drop me a message first.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate